Baseball history is full of managers who are famous for all sorts of reasons. Some are known for their unmatched success, others for their failures, and some for a particular moment or antics. Buck Showalter’s story is like that of most ballplayers. He never made it to the majors as a player and after his playing days ended, he turned to coaching the game he loved. That is where his story differs from the rest of us. Showalter became one of the most respected baseball minds of his generation and had a long run coaching at the highest level.
Before Yankees fans knew him as the intense manager who expected all the little things to be done right and who helped restore order to the franchise in the early 1990s, Showalter was simply another minor leaguer trying to survive the grind of professional baseball. That journey, and the way he carried himself through it, helped shape the leader baseball fans would eventually come to admire.
William Nathaniel “Buck” Showalter III
Born: May 23, 1956 (DeFuniak Springs, FL)
Yankees Tenure: 1977-91 (coach/minor-league player); 1992-95 (manager)
Before becoming “Buck,” Showalter was mostly known as “Nat.” Born William Nathaniel Showalter III, he went by his middle name throughout much of his younger life, including during his playing days at Chipola College and Mississippi State. The nickname “Buck” reportedly came from a tendency of liking to lounge in the minor-league clubhouses naked. Like many baseball nicknames, it simply stuck.
Showalter built an impressive amateur career before the Yankees selected the outfielder in the fifth round of the 1977 MLB Draft. At Mississippi State, Showalter helped establish himself as one of the better college players in the Southeast while earning All-SEC honors and eventually landing in the school’s Athletic Hall of Fame.
After signing with New York, Showalter spent several seasons climbing through the Yankees minor league system at both first base and in the outfield. He hit well at times and became known for his work ethic and baseball intelligence, but he never quite broke through onto the big-league roster, topping out in Triple-A Columbus. It didn’t help that as he became more of a first baseman, he was overshadowed by another up-and-coming late-1970s draft pick who played alongside him at Double-A Nashville in 1981: Don Mattingly.
In many organizations, and for most players, that likely would have marked the end of the story. Instead, for Showalter it became the beginning.
Following the end of his playing career in 1983, Showalter quickly transitioned into coaching within the Yankees organization. His attention to detail, preparation, and ability to connect with players rapidly earned him respect throughout baseball circles. By the late 1980s and early 1990s, Showalter became one of the quickest rising managerial prospects in the sport, earning praise and awards throughout his stops skippering Oneonta, Fort Lauderdale, and Albany-Colonie. Soon-to-be-familiar names emerged under his watch, including Bernie Williams and Jim Leyritz.
Showalter got his first taste of The Show on the coaching staffs of Bucky Dent and Stump Merrill in 1990 and 1991. General manager Gene “Stick” Michael grew to trust his keen eye, and it wasn’t long before those lousy Yankees teams ushered in an opening at the head of the dugout for the 35-year-old at the start of 1992, making him the youngest full-time manager in Yankees history.
The Yankees hired Showalter during one of the more unstable stretches in franchise history. Owner George Steinbrenner’s reputation and suspension loomed over the organization, and the Yankees were desperately searching for direction. “Stick” needed a coach who could help mold the upcoming young talent he was drafting and, for once, not being forced to trade away.
Showalter’s tenure as Yankees manager lasted just four seasons, but each year represented steady progress for a franchise trying to climb out of the chaos of the late 1980s. The Yankees finished 76-86 in his first season managing in 1992 before improving to 88-74 in 1993, narrowly missing the postseason despite playing meaningful September baseball for the first time in several years. He had the trust of his old teammate-turned-Yankees captain Mattingly, veterans like Paul O’Neill and Wade Boggs thrived under him, and Williams and Leyritz began to find their footing. Showalter’s attention to detail as skipper was nonpareil, as while he could be straitlaced, no one doubted his acumen.
In 1994, the Yankees owned the best record in the American League at 70-43 before the players’ strike abruptly ended the season and erased what many believed was a legitimate championship opportunity. Showalter was named the Manager of the Year and skipper of the 1995 AL All-Star team in what must have all felt like a consolation trophy (as did the famous Seinfeld cameo).
Once the dust settled on the strike, the Yankees went back to work on returning to postseason play for the first time since 1981. They had high hopes after 1994, but found themselves nine games under .500 on June 20th, and while they played better in July, a subpar post-Trade Deadline showing had them at 54-59 on the morning of August 29th. It looked like it would be yet another quiet October in the Bronx, as Boston was running away with the AL East and even with the recent advent of the Wild Card, they trailed six teams in that race. Given that the quick-trigger-finger Steinbrenner was long since reinstated, Showalter’s job was in jeopardy — though Stick always had his back.
Suddenly, the Yankees caught fire as Labor Day approached. They took five straight against the Angels and A’s, narrowly lost two out of their next three, and then reeled off another six wins in a row. Indeed, September would feature two more winning streaks of at least five games as the Yankees made a furious charge to the Wild Card lead with an incredible 22-6 final month under Showalter. With heroics down the stretch from the likes of Mattingly, O’Neill, trade acquistion David Cone, rookie Andy Pettitte, and even light-hitting second baseman Pat Kelly, the Yankees clinched a playoff spot in Toronto on the season’s last day.
As the final out was clinched, Buck could only watch with pride from the dugout, not immediately joining in on the handshake line because in his words, “That’s their moment.” But after a minute, he did take the field to congratulate his players, closing on an especially meaningful hug with Mattingly. Both men had lived and died with every second of the organization’s 14-year playoff drought and were emotional in the postgame celebration.
View Link
The ALDS against the Mariners featured incredible highs as the Yankees won the first two games in the Bronx in dramatic fashion. Unfortunately, it all unraveled when the series shifted to the Kingdome. The Yankees dropped three in a row, losing a heartbreaking series that would ultimately became the end of Showalter’s Yankees tenure.
In wake of the loss to Seattle, Steinbrenner chose to offer Showalter a new contract, but it came with a condition: the majority of the coaching staff had to be fired. Four coaches in particular—Rick Down, Mark Connor, Brian Butterfield, and Glenn Sherlock—could not be back on staff. Additionally, despite Showalter asking for a three-year contract, Steinbrenner refused to offer more than two years.
Showalter dug in and declined the Yankees offer, ending his time in the Bronx despite the clear upward trajectory of the organization. As the skipper for four seasons, Showalter managed the Yankees to a 313-268-1 record.
One year later, the Yankees won the 1996 World Series under Joe Torre. It is impossible to ignore that Showalter helped establish the structure, accountability, and expectations for a young core that would eventually define a generation.
Showalter walked away uncertain, as he had no jobs lined up and had only been in the Yankees organization as a working adult. However, he would not be unemployed long as he was offered and became the first manager in Arizona Diamondbacks history. Showalter, along with the four coaches he refused to fire, went to Arizona tasked with building an expansion franchise from the ground up, hired over two years before the D-backs would even play a game.
The move became legendary among coaches who appreciated the loyalty and dedication he showed to his staff. Much like he had in New York, Showalter helped establish structure and organizational expectations almost immediately.
The Diamondbacks went from a 65-win expansion team in 1998 to a 100-win playoff club in 1999. However, after Arizona regressed in 2000 and ownership tensions reportedly surfaced, Showalter was dismissed in early October.
One year later, the Bob Brenly-led Diamondbacks defeated the Yankees in a dramatic seven-game World Series, ending New York’s dynasty run at a fourth straight championship with Torre. In one of baseball’s strangest twists of fate, and even more painful for Yankees fans, the team Showalter helped mold in the desert became the group that finally stopped the dynasty.
Timing has always made Showalter one of baseball’s most fascinating “what if” figures. A strike took out his chance at a ring in 1994. The Yankees won the World Series the year after he departed, while the Diamondbacks also captured a championship the year after replacing him as manager. Fair or unfair, Showalter is “the guy before the guy.” To date, he is the winningest manager in MLB history (1,727 wins, 19th all-time) to never reach a Fall Classic, trailing only Gene Mauch.
Showalter’s post-Arizona career cemented his reputation as one of baseball’s great developers. After spending time in television and around the game as much as he could, he returned to the dugout with the Texas Rangers in 2003.
Showalter’s first year in Texas was surrounded by drama most of which was caused by Alex Rodriguez. Due to that drama and his huge contract, Rodriguez was traded to the Yankees during the 2004 offseason. Despite trading their star, the club found a way to end up with a winning record at 89-73 and those efforts were rewarded with a second Manager of the Year title. However, the Rangers would falter in 2005 and 2006 slipping below .500 both years. Showalter and the Rangers parted ways after the 2006 season.
Showalter returned to TV work until he was hired in Baltimore by the Orioles in July 2010. He quickly helped transform one of baseball’s worst organizations into a contender. Buck became beloved in the Charm City, which became one of the few places where you’d actually see fans wearing merchandise with the manager’s name and number on the back.
In 2012, the Orioles ended a streak of 14 consecutive losing seasons, as Showalter took the Orioles to their first playoff berth since 1997 and his first since 1999. They beat the Rangers in the first AL Wild Card Game before falling to his old Yankees (and Raúl Ibañez) in a five-game ALDS. Under his leadership, the O’s reached the postseason three times, including a 96-win division-winning season in 2014 that earned Showalter the Manager of the Year award for the third time. The swept a pitching-rich Tigers club in the Division Series before getting dusted themselves up the upstart Royals in the ALCS. It still stands as Baltimore’s longest playoff run within the last 29 years.
The O’s would lose steam and eventually bottom out in 2018. Showalter was dismissed during regime change from Dan Duquette to Mike Elias. His 669 regular-season wins rank second in franchise history, trailing only the Hall of Famer Earl Weaver. Showalter would once more return to TV, but hoped to coach again.
The Mets and former Yankees assistant general manager Billy Eppler gave him that chance for the 2022 campaign. Showalter helped guide little brother to a 101-win campaign and earned yet another Manager of the Year honor — though the Mets lost a division lead down the stretch to the hard-charging Braves and then fell to the Padres in a three-game Wild Card Series. Even though postseason success often proved elusive, Showalter’s career repeatedly followed the same pattern: struggling organizations became respectable, young players developed, and teams learned how to expect more from themselves after Buck arrived.
Tasting success, the Mets would “go for it” in free agency during the winter of 2022-23. Showalter and the club failed to meet expectations, and he was dismissed as manager following the 2023 season, as owner Steve Cohen granted new front-office head David Stearns the right to pick his own manager (Carlos Mendoza).
Showalter has been out of coaching since those two years in Queens, but he’s back working in TV as an analyst for MLB Network. Althoguh he’s still interested in managing, it’s hard to get those jobs at age-70, so his career in the dugout might be at an end. In total, Showalter spent 22 seasons as a professional manager, with a 1,727-1,665-1 record good for a .509 winning percentage. Only Dusty Baker guided more different teams to the postseason than Buck’s four.
Loved by so many fans, one might wonder why Showalter wore out his welcome so many times. Other than his run with the O’s, he never lasted more than four seasons managing a clubhouse. Showalter’s greatest strengths might also have been his biggest weaknesses. A player’s coach, Showalter loved conversations, teaching, and bonding with his players, viewing his role as helping them navigate life along with baseball. However, he demanded preparation and accountability with a hyper-focus on details. A little headstrong once he determined his mindset, he often prioritized player and coaching relationships over the front office and ownership.
Regardless of how long he could survive before getting voted off the island, Showalter’s ability to lead a turnaround is legendary. Often leadership gets framed entirely around sacrifice, toughness, or authority. His career serves as a reminder that leadership can also look like care, availability, consistency, and unwavering support. Even if Showalter himself would probably brush off those compliments, many former players and coaches clearly saw him as exactly that type of leader.
That humanity helps explain why Showalter remains beloved by so many baseball fans despite never fully getting the championship moment many believe he deserved. Across multiple organizations, players consistently respected him, front offices trusted him, even if those relationships strained over time, and fans connected with the authenticity he brought to the dugout every day.
Showalter never got the storybook championship, but baseball history would feel incomplete without him. Some leaders become famous for the dynasties they led. Others deserve to be remembered for helping build the foundation.
Happy birthday Buck!
See more of the “Yankees Birthday of the Day” series here.
Read the full article here