The Colorado Rockies always seem to a find their way into an outfield logjam. Admittedly, it took them slightly longer this year, but with Mickey Moniak beginning a rehab assignment with the Triple-Albuquerque Isotopes on Thursday—while Brenton Doyle and Jordan Beck are potentially nearing their own rehab assignments—things are about to get more crowded.
The Rockies currently have six players on the active roster designated as or able to play as outfielders. Including the three on the injured list, they’ve fielded nine different outfielders this season. The team also has two prospects in Triple-A that are getting closer and closer to big league call-ups. Once Moniak returns to the active roster—which is expected to happen as early as this Sunday against the Pittsburgh Pirates—the Rockies will have decisions to make when it comes to their outfield.
Here are the outfielders the Rockies have used to far.
Willi Castro, 1.0 rWAR
The switch-hitting Willi Castro is mostly an infielder for the Rockies this year, regularly playing a serviceable second base with a smattering of shortstop. However, he has decent experience playing in the outfield and has made nine appearances with 27 innings in the outfield. Most of his reps have come in left field, though he’s also had time in center. During that time he has five putouts with an assist and took part in a double play.
At the plate, Castro has turned into a consistent contributor. As of today he’s hitting .282/.359/.409 with 13 doubles, five home runs, and 32 RBIs, a 24.6% strikeout rate, and a 9.4% walk rate.
Troy Johnston, 0.2 rWAR
Johnston’s big personality and quality hitting has been one of the most delightful adds to the Rockies roster this season. Johnston is hitting .312/.373/.440 with three home runs, 34 RBIs, a 17.7% strikeout rate, and a 7.7% walk rate. His 21 doubles are the second most in Major League Baseball.
Defensively, Johnston has been… an adventure, worth -5 defensive runs saved, -2 outs above average, and a -2 fielding run value. Most of his reps have come in right field, though he’s fared slightly better in left. The less said about his glove-work at first base, the better.
Brenton Doyle, -0.4 rWAR
After a miserable first half in 2025, Brenton Doyle turned things around and looked much more like the starting center fielder and two-time Gold Glove winner Rockies fans had seen in 2023 and 2024. Then he got off to another rough start in 2026.
Before hitting the injured list with an oblique contusion, Doyle had been hitting just .207/.279/.270 with just four doubles, one home run, and four RBIs. He had also stolen nine bases. In center field his defense had been—by the standard he has set in previous seasons—poor with -2 defensive runs saved, zero outs above average, and a -1 fielding run value.
View Link
Jordan Beck, -0.4 rWAR
Much like Doyle, Jordan Beck was off to a difficult start in 2026 before landing on the injured list. Beck was hitting only .183/.227/.305 with five doubles, one triple, one home run, and ten RBIs until getting sidelined with a hamstring strain. While hitting well against left-handed pitchers, his bat against right-handed pitchers was dire with just three total hits in 44 at-bats.
Beck’s defense has been fine this season, though he does better in left field than he does in right. As a left fielder he’s been worth two defensive runs saved with both zero outs above average and fielding run value. In right field he’s worth zero defensive runs saved and outs above average with a -2 fielding run value.
View Link
Jake McCarthy, 0.0 rWAR
The surprise in-division trade with the Arizona Diamondbacks this off-season that brought Jake McCarthy into the fold seems to be paying off. McCarthy is hitting .288/.332/.445 with 12 doubles, three triples, four home runs, 27 RBIs, and 11 stolen bases.
Defensively, McCarthy has been a bit of a mixed bag. His truly excellent sprint speed and range makes him an ideal fit for center field, but he’s hindered by a weak arm. In center field he’s worth -4 defensive runs saved, zero outs above average, and has a fielding run value of one. With the emergence of other center field options, McCarthy has recently been playing more left field where he’s worth one out above average but zero defensive runs saved.
Tyler Freeman, -0.5 rWAR
Tyler Freeman has been one of the Rockies’ most consistent hitters over the last two seasons. While he doesn’t have much power—despite three home runs this season—he doesn’t strike out much and gets on base. He’s hitting .267/.348/.366 with just an 11.9% strikeout rate.
Freeman has found himself as a regular in right field for the Rockies, but his defense has dragged down his player value by wins above replacement into the negatives. He has a strong, but inaccurate arm and is worth -5 defensive runs saved and -1 outs above average. Freeman has made some legitimately good plays in right field this year, but more often than not his defense is subpar.
View Link
Mickey Moniak, 0.9 rWAR
Before hitting the injured list with ankle tendonitis and foot swelling, Mickey Moniak looked to be a potential All-Star candidate for the Rockies. He was hitting .280/.335/.607 with nine doubles, two triples, 12 home runs, and 28 RBIs—though most of his success came against right-handed pitchers.
Like Freeman, Moniak’s value in 2025 suffered immensely due to poor defense. In 2026, Moniak was already worth -2 outs above average and fielding run value in right field over just 66 innings. However, a move to left has cleaned things up immensely. Moniak’s left field defense has been perfectly serviceable with zero defensive runs saved but one out above average and fielding run value. Ironic considering he can’t hit against lefties (5-for-28).
Sterlin Thompson, -0.2 rWAR
The first of two outfield MLB debuts this season, Florida product Sterlin Thompson (no. 13 PuRP) has been taking good at-bats but hasn’t quite unlocked the results to go along with them. Thompson is hitting .234/.319/.391 with four doubles, but recently hit his first two home runs and even got to experience some walk-off heroics.
Thompson has played a lot of defensive positions in his collegiate and professional career, but seems to have settled largely in left field. Right now he’s worth -1 in both defensive runs saved, outs above average, and fielding run value. Interestingly, Thompson has more big league starts as a designated hitter than he does in the outfield.
Cole Carrigg, 0.2 rWAR
One of the Rockies’ top prospects, Cole Carrigg (no. 4 PuRP) was a surprising relatively early call-up this season after a red-hot start in Triple-A Albuquerque. While he’s not quite hitting for average while slashing .222/.333/.528, four of his first eight big league hits are for extra bases and three have been home runs. Carrigg has more home runs and RBIs (8) than Brenton Doyle in a fourth of the games played and is four years younger than his center field teammate.
While his defense still needs to be refined, Carrigg has both the speed and range for center field and an absolute cannon of an arm—one of the best in the Rockies’ system and on par with Doyle’s. He represents one of the more difficult decisions the Rockies might need to make when Doyle begins a rehab assignment. Do you go with the two-time Gold Glove winner, or do you go with the much younger prospect with higher upside?
View Link
Final Thoughts
The Rockies have used nine different outfielders so far this season, but those outfielders have combined for just 0.8 wins above replacement per Baseball Reference. That’s also being generous by including Willi Castro, who has accumulated most of his WAR in the infield. Without Castro, the group is worth -0.2 rWAR.
It’s worth noting just how bad the group as a whole has been defensively. The Rockies outfield group is the second-worst in Major League Baseball with -20 defensive runs saved and are in the bottom ten league-wide when it comes to outs above average (-6) and fielding run value (-7).
At the plate there have been plenty of contributions, but outside of Moniak and Freeman it’s all been from newcomers. Doyle and Beck have both struggled at the plate before their respective injuries and now it feels like the pair—once potential pillars of the team’s future—could now be very replaceable. Especially when there are two more top prospects preparing to break down the door in Triple-A Albuquerque right now.
After a disastrous MLB debut last season, a newly sober and bulked up Zac Veen (no. 9 PuRP) has been tearing the cover off the ball with the Isotopes. He’s hitting .328/.416/.573 with 18 doubles, four triples, 11 home runs, and 48 RBIs. He’s seeing the ball well, drawing walks, and still has the speed to make him dangerous despite his new size. Veen can also play all three outfield positions.
Meanwhile, with the emergence of TJ Rumfield as a potential first baseman of the future, 2024 first round pick Charlie Condon (no. 1 PuRP) has been getting plenty of work in right field this season with the Isotopes. After a slow start, he’s also found his power stroke and is hitting 261/.392/.517 with 13 doubles, three triples, 14 home runs, and 44 RBIs.
It would be shocking of president of baseball operations Paul DePodesta and his new-look Rockies front office wasn’t already using the information above to plan for the Rockies’ future in the outfield. However, the time to start making decisions with this crowded group is coming up quicker than expected. Two rookies have already made their debut with another on the way and Veen is making a strong case for another crack at the bigs. Three injured outfielders are coming closer to returning.The trade deadline is less than two months away.
You can’t carry 11 outfielders on a 26-man active roster. At the same time, simply saying “trade everyone you can and designate everyone else for assignment” isn’t necessarily realistic. Sometimes trades don’t materialize, or a return simply isn’t good enough. On the other hand, do you designate someone like Brenton Doyle for assignment if you can’t trade him when he is capable of elite center field defense when healthy?
What does the outfield group look like—both starters and bench players—after Moniak is reinstated? What does that group look like after the August 3rd trade deadline? Let us know your thoughts in the comments.
Join the conversation!
Sign up for a user account and get:
-
Comment on articles, community posts
-
Rec comments, community posts
-
New, improved notifications system!
Please keep in mind our Purple Row Community Guidelines when you’re commenting. Thanks!
Read the full article here
