Scottie Scheffler’s dominant victory at the CJ Cup Byron Nelson has been both celebrated and criticised, as some in the golf community question the strength of the field and the quality of the course at TPC Craig Ranch.
While Scheffler posted an outstanding 72-hole total of 253, tying a PGA Tour record, critics argue that his performance was aided by a venue many believe doesn’t offer the challenges expected at a top-tier event.
Scottie Scheffler entered the CJ Cup Byron Nelson as the clear favourite, with most of the best betting sites not on GamStop UK in 2025 offering odds around 11/4 for the world number one. His strong form and dominance in key stats led many punters to back him confidently. Fans expected a standout performance from Scheffler, and he delivered exactly that.
The course, which has ranked near the bottom of Golf Digest’s state listings and Tour scoring difficulty stats, is often referred to as underwhelming by players, caddies, and broadcasters alike.
A combination of flat terrain, low wind exposure, and predictable conditions has led to unusually low scores, diminishing the perception of competitiveness.
The storm delays that interrupted the tournament only added to frustrations surrounding the Dallas-area course. Despite a $22.5 million renovation plan now in motion, some feel the problems extend beyond the course layout, pointing to its inconvenient location and lack of prestige within the PGA Tour calendar.
In response to these concerns, a comprehensive redevelopment project overseen by Lanny Wadkins is underway. The aim is to elevate the course through turf upgrades and design changes that align it with elite venues across the country.
However, this effort comes at a time when the reputation of TPC Craig Ranch is already under pressure, and even a record-setting performance like Scheffler’s isn’t enough to silence doubts from all quarters.
Adding to the scepticism was a recent podcast discussion that framed Scheffler’s win as less meaningful given the perceived weakness of the field. The CJ Cup Byron Nelson, while offering full Tour status, is not considered among the season’s marquee events.
For some observers, the low level of competition and the forgiving course made it difficult to evaluate Scheffler’s true form heading into more prestigious tournaments.
Scheffler, however, seems determined to shift the narrative by performing at venues with more demanding conditions. He has opted out of the Truist Championship to focus on preparing for the PGA Championship at Quail Hollow, also known as the “Green Mile”, a course known for testing every aspect of a golfer’s game.
With his strong record in the first major of the season, where he finished fourth, the signs suggest he may be rounding into shape.
His statistics back that up. Scheffler ranks near the top in several critical metrics, particularly in tee-to-green performance.
His strokes gained off the tee place him among the elite, highlighting his ability to combine distance and control. While not the longest hitter on Tour, his consistency in hitting fairways and maintaining solid driving accuracy puts him in advantageous positions.
These traits will be vital at Quail Hollow, which punishes errant drives and rewards strategic play.
Scheffler’s total driving rank, a measure of both length and accuracy, supports the idea that he’s well-equipped for the challenges ahead.
Though his driving distance places him in the middle of the pack, his top-25 ranking in accuracy demonstrates a level of precision that few can match.
At Quail Hollow, where course management and execution off the tee are critical, these strengths may help him deliver the kind of performance that earns respect from both fans and sceptics.
As the PGA Championship approaches, the focus will shift from TPC Craig Ranch’s flaws to whether Scheffler can replicate his form at a course with a far tougher reputation.
A strong showing, or even a win, at Quail Hollow could go a long way in reasserting his place among the most respected players on Tour, and perhaps finally quiet the lingering doubts surrounding his most recent triumph.
Read the full article here