The Mets and Pirates went to extra innings in a low-scoring affair for the second day in a row, but this time there were no walk-off fireworks by the home team, as the Mets fell to Pittsburgh 4-3 in ten innings.
Things got off to a nervy start immediately for Nolan McLean, who had trouble finding the strike zone in the first, walking the first two batters he faced. He bounced back to strike out the next batter, but then Ryan O’Hearn blooped a single to left to put the Pirates on the board. Carmen Mlodzinski got off to a strong start by contrast, striking out the side in the bottom of the first.
But after McLean rebounded with a quick 1-2-3 second, the Mets tied up the game in the bottom of the frame. Luis Robert, striding to the plate to a robust ovation from the Citi Field crowd after last night’s heroics, hit a one-out single past the third baseman Nick Gonzales; the ball was hit sharply right at Gonzales, but he failed to come up with it and it sparked a rally for the Mets. Brett Baty followed with a single up the middle, advancing Robert to third. Marcus Semien then tied the game at one run apiece with a sacrifice fly. The Mets threatened for more, as Jared Triolo bobbled a Carson Benge grounder, allowing him to reach base safely, but Luis Torrens struck out looking to end the threat.
The Pirates immediately jumped back ahead in the third on a solo home run by who else but Brandon Lowe, who has killed the Mets all series long. It was the first home run McLean has allowed to a lefty in the major leagues. Mlodzinski responded to being given a lead to work with by striking out the side again in the third, setting his career-high for strikeouts. McLean countered with a 1-2-3 inning of his own in the top of the fourth. The Mets threatened in the bottom of the fourth thanks to back-to-back one-out singles by Robert and Baty again, but they did not score. The Pirates had a chance to extend their lead in the top of the fifth with a one-out bloop just over Bichette’s head that rolled into foul territory by Lowe that he stretched all the way into a double with some heads up base running. McLean managed to strike out Bryan Reynolds looking for the second out, thanks to some generous calls by the home plate umpire that Reynolds inexplicably chose not to challenge. McLean struck out Ryan O’Hearn as well to end the inning and hold the Pirates to two runs, ending his afternoon after five innings of work, over which he struck out eight Pirates and walked two.
The Mets got McLean off the hook by tying the game in the bottom of the fifth. With one out, Francisco Lindor hit a rocket off the wall in right-center that was not far away from leaving the yard and slid into third base safely with a triple. Juan Soto drove him in with an RBI single to tie the game. That ended Carmen Mlodzinski’s day and former Met Yohan Ramírez retired Bo Bichette—who has looked rough at the plate in the early going and looked particularly bad in this game—and Jorge Polanco to stymie the rally.
Huascar Brazobán needed just five pitches to retire the Pirates in order in the sixth and then recorded the first two outs of the seventh as well before making way for Sean Manaea, whose reduced velocity seems to have not yet rebounded. Manaea looked shaky, but ultimately got the job done. He allowed a two-out single to Oneil Cruz and made a throwing error on a pickoff attempt that allowed the go-ahead run to get into scoring position. But Marcus Semien made a nice place on a sharp grounder to second off the bat of Lowe to help Manaea escape the jam. The Mets rallied but failed to score again in the bottom of the seventh, this time against Mason Montgomery. Montgomery proved to be a tough left-on-left matchup for Carson Benge, who struck out to lead off the inning. But Luis Torrens then hit a slow roller down the third base line that stayed fair for an infield single. Lindor then singled and a wild pitch advanced the runners to second and third, but Montgomery struck out Soto and Bichette back-to-back to wriggle his way out of the jam. After striking out the first two batters he faced in the eighth, Manaea walked two consecutive batters, but Nick Gonzales grounded out to end the inning, as both teams maintained their low success rate in the game with runners in scoring position.
Isaac Mattson contributed a 1-2-3 bottom of the eighth for Pittsburgh and Luke Weaver worked around a pair of walks to pitch a scoreless ninth for the Mets. Don Kelly turned to his closer Dennis Santana for the third time in as many games and Santana pitched a 1-2-3 ninth to send the game into extras for the second straight day. And for the second straight day the Mets sent Dicky Lovelady to the mound in a tie game in extra innings. It worked yesterday, but it did not work today and Lovelady ended up being the losing pitcher after having been the winning pitcher in yesterday’s thrilling victory. Ryan O’Hearn, the batter Lovelady was likely in there to match up against, singled to lead off the tenth and score the ghost runner. But Lovelady bounced back to induce a double play grounder from Jared Triolo and it seemed—just like yesterday—like Lovelady might just manage to escape the inning having yielded just the one unearned run. Unfortunately, Lovelady walked the next two batters and then Henry Davis laced an RBI single to give the Pirates a 4-2 lead.
That extra run is what would make the difference. The Mets had the top of the order up against José Urquidy in the bottom of the tenth and Francisco Lindor got things off to an encouraging start by drawing a seven-pitch walk. Juan Soto then muscled a double deep into the gap in left-center to plate the Mets’ third run, but Lindor was tagged out at home as the tying run, letting all the air out of what was perhaps building to another come-from-behind victory in extras. Bichette then grounded out to short for the second out and Soto advanced to third base. There was one last spark of hope when Jorge Polanco gave the first pitch he saw from Urquidy a ride to deep right field and for the briefest of moments, it seemed like the Mets may have just done it again, but Billy Cook (in the game as a pinch runner and defensive replacement) secured the ball right up against the right field wall to end the game.
SB Nation GameThreads
Amazin’ Avenue
Bucs Dugout
Box scores
MLB.com
ESPN
Win Probability Added
What’s WPA?
Big Mets winner: Francisco Lindor, +34.5% WPA
Big Mets loser: Dicky Lovelady, -41.5% WPA
Mets pitchers: -1.2% WPA
Mets hitters: -48.8% WPA
Teh aw3s0mest play: Francisco Lindor’s leadoff walk in the bottom of the tenth, +23.0% WPA
Teh sux0rest play: Ryan O’Hearn’s go-ahead RBI single in the top of the tenth off Dicky Lovelady, -36.7% WPA
Read the full article here
