Heading into the 2026 MLB Draft, there were a number of directions the Yankees could take to kick off their selections off. There was speculation that the team would go for a catcher to improve one of the thinnest areas of depth within the organization, and they’ve overall tended to lean towards hitters at the top of the draft class. With the 35th pick in the draft, they instead chose to go for a pitcher, taking Hunter Dietz out of Arkansas.
Dietz was a nationally ranked prospect coming out of high school from Cavalry Christian High (Clearwater, FL), and is a junior in college, but he really only has college experience from this past season as he pitched 1.2 innings combined in his first two years at Arkansas following surgery to repair a stress fracture in his elbow. A looming lefty standing at 6-foot-6, Dietz made his return to the mound in 2026 and dominated in the Southeastern Conference, posting a 3.57 ERA with 131 strikeouts in 85.2 innings, good for a 36.2 percent strikeout rate.
Rankings on Dietz range from an expected spot to be selected to a decent steal, as Baseball America ranked him 34th overall on their list while MLB Pipeline gave him their 17th overall placement and The Athletic placing him as high as 12th overall. Scouts have raved about his fastball-slider combination, and MLB Pipeline rated both as 60-grade pitches thanks to Dietz sitting in the high 90s with the heater while his slider is drawing swing and misses more than 50 percent of the time. There’s consensus across the scouting reports that Dietz is on the shortlist for best college left-hander in this draft with plenty of teams considering him the best, and while the lost couple of years might’ve scared off teams in the front half of the first round the Yankees benefitted from him falling into their lap.
The strength of the Yankees’ farm system the last couple of years has been their pitching pipeline, and they’ve added a potential gem to the pile with Dietz in the mix. He has the potential to be a fast riser, but there’s also plenty of risk to manage here. The Yankees are no strangers to SEC starters, and I see a bit of a parallel to when the team landed Clarke Schmidt out of the 2017 Draft. Schmidt’s injury happened in reverse, seeing him undergo Tommy John surgery to conclude his college career, but the body of work he already had was enough for the Yankees to take him with the 16th overall pick and he blossomed into a fine MLB starter for them.
Now that the team has made their selection, they’ll be back to waiting until their next turn comes around with the 63rd pick in the Draft. What do you think of their choice to go for a pitcher with Hunter Dietz? Let us know down below!
Read the full article here